About This Orbit: Mel Tomlinson

Strong and handsome dancer Mel Tomlinson holding a passé position.
Mel Tomlinson – Courtesy of The Academy at Terpsicorps.
Click above to explore the Mel Tomlinson orbit in MoBBallet’s Constellation Project

Mel Tomlinson was a strong asset to multiple American ballet companies in his lifetime, dancing all over the country, bringing modern technique and stunning skill to the ballet stage. He got his start at Heritage Dance Theatre in North Carolina, but also performed with Dance Theatre of Harlem, Alvin Ailey American Dance Theater, New York City Ballet, North Carolina Dance Theatre, and Boston Ballet. He danced both principal and soloist roles at these various companies and got to work with many different choreographers and dancers. According to the 🔑 New York Amsterdam News, his favorite piece to perform was Manifestations at Dance Theatre of Harlem in 1976. In this role, he was make to dance like a snake and actually bought a pet snake as a learning tool to enhance his performance, emphasizing his dedication to his craft. Tomlinson was an advocate for getting more underrepresented and low-income students into the dance world, so at Boston Ballet, he helped start the CITYDANCE initiative, a way to get inner city youth on stage and build the next generation of dancers. After retiring, he returned to his old middle school in Raleigh and taught classes for the students there. Tomlinson’s legacy lives on through the iconic work he performed and through his dedication to outreach programs that are still thriving today. In his memoir, Beyond My Dreams, Tomlinson said, “There is one thing that I believe we, as dancers, all have in common; it is our desire not to be forgotten.” Tomlinson left his mark on the dance world by working professionally in six different companies, and this orbit follows Tomlinson through his career, mapping the people and institutions with which he intersected, to ensure that he is never forgotten.


Agnes de Mille (Heritage Dance Theatre)

Tomlinson got his start at Heritage Dance Theatre thanks to Agnes de Mille. In 1974, de Mille revived her company (Agnes de Mille Dance Theatre) under the name Heritage Dance Theatre, in collaboration with the University of North Carolina School of the Arts, where Tomlinson attended as an undergraduate. Tomlinson remembers in his memoir, Beyond Mr Dreams, that he was initially cut from Agnes de Mille’s audition at school for the company, but thanks to his teacher, was given another chance, where he demonstrated his many tricks, such as riding a unicycle and twirling a baton. Afterwards, Tomlinson was selected as a principal dancer in this company and began touring right after graduation. Agnes de Mille created a ballet called Texas Fourth, in which Tomlinson had multiple solo moments to show off his tricks. The ballets showcased while the company was on tour were true to the American spirit, thanks to de Mille’s fascination with The West; this connected Americans with the ballet world and the history of the nation. Agnes de Mille and Mel Tomlinson shared a rather special connection while on tour because, as the company was moving through the deep South, there were plenty of people that were unfriendly towards Tomlinson and the three other Black dancers. So de Mille took it upon herself to protect them. The tour culminated in a performance at the Metropolitan Opera House in New York City’s Lincoln Center for a gala.


Arthur Mitchell (Dance Theatre of Harlem)

Mel Tomlinson and 4 dancers from Dance Theatre of Harlem in The Four Temperments, a ballet by George Balanchine.
Four Temperaments by George Balanchine. Photo: Marbeth. Dancers: Linda Swayze, Julie Felix, Mel Tomlinson, Stephanie Dabney, Elena Carter-Wyatt. Photo Credit: Dance Theatre of Harlem.

After graduating from the North Carolina School of the Arts, Tomlinson accepted an invitation from Dance Theatre of Harlem to dance professionally. This, however, was not the first time that Tomlinson had been offered to dance with the company. According to his memoir, Tomlinson remembers that he was offered a full scholarship to DTH’s summer program and was then invited to stay and join the company. Tomlinson, while excited at the offer, declined in order to finish out his schooling and get a college degree, a rather unprecedented move for most dancers. Tomlinson had graduated through the modern program, so it was Arthur Mitchell who taught him the technique of ballet and the vocabulary. Eventually, Tomlinson worked his way up to the rank of soloist. Mitchell and Tomlinson were said to be like a father-son duo, to the point that when Tomlinson asked to leave the company, Mitchell said a spot for him would always be there, and two years later, Tomlinson grew homesick and came back to Dance Theatre of Harlem. That’s not to say they didn’t have their tense moments, but out of love and respect for each other, they were a great team. Tomlinson’s favorite piece performed at DTH was Manifestations in 1976, which was based on the story of Adam and Eve, in which Tomlinson played the snake. His grand entrance was coming down from the ceiling on an invisible wire, which captivated audiences night after night.


Alvin Ailey

Mel Tomlinson was a dancer who was never satisfied. After a few years of dancing with Dance Theatre of Harlem, Tomlinson wanted a new challenge and decided to leave the company. Several days later, while taking class at Alvin Ailey’s school, Ailey asked Tomlinson if he’d like to join his company now that he’d left DTH. According to the 🔑 New York Amsterdam News, Tomlinson was initially shocked and had to think it over, “‘but in five minutes I was signing the contracts.’” In Tomlinson, Ailey saw a new partner for Judith Jamison. Tomlinson credits Alvin Ailey for bringing modern back into his life and loosening him up a bit after years of ballet discipline. Thanks to Ailey, Tomlinson found “the total joy of movement.”


Judith Jamison

Judith Jamison performed Pas de Duke with Tomlinson in 1976, soon after he joined Alvin Ailey American Dance Theater. Tomlinson was a part of Alvin Ailey’s company for two years, but this was one of his more memorable performances. The piece is supposed to show the differences between ballet and modern while having the two dancers in a sort of playful competition. According to the 🔑 New York Amsterdam News, Tomlinson said that he admired Jamison as a role model and continued to follow her career after they parted ways at Alvin Ailey. One of Tomlinson’s motivations for joining to company was the fact that he would have the chance to partner Jamison. He remembers that Jamison kept him in the moment when they danced together, as she challenged him often by dancing circles around him.

Sara Yarborough

While in Alvin Ailey’s company, Tomlinson also danced one of his more famous pieces, The Time Before The Time After, with Sara Yarborough, in 1977. According to 🔑The New York Times, “there is no doubt that they have a performing spark.” This dance, while focusing more on lust rather than love, involves a series of embraces and repeated movements, emphasizing the circle that the piece is about. Due to their immediate connection and strong background, they were able to focus more of their energy into the acting involved in the roles, taking their artistry to a whole new level.

George Balanchine (New York City Ballet)

A studio portrait of Mel Tomlinson at New York City Ballet.
New York City Ballet dancer Mel Tomlinson in a studio portrait in costume for The Four Temperaments, choreography by George Balanchine.

Tomlinson eventually grew homesick and returned to Dance Theatre of Harlem, where he was spotted by none other than George Balanchine of New York City Ballet, and soon after, Tomlinson was the only African American dancer in the company. Balanchine had always had a grand dream of a ballet class with eight white students and eight Black students, with four males and four females of each skin color. Balanchine chose to hire Tomlinson as he continued to strive for the truly “American” New York City Ballet company that he dreamed of. However, this was not the first instance that their paths had crossed—that was when Arthur Mitchell brought Tomlinson downtown to meet with Balanchine, as Tomlinson was initially selected to fill a role in the film The Spellbound Child for Mitchell. While with NYCB, Tomlinson took on roles that had previously been performed by Mitchell, who used to be the only Black dancer in the company before leaving to form Dance Theatre of Harlem. Balanchine saw similarities between Mitchell and Tomlinson, and saw Tomlinson as Mitchell’s “legacy” being reborn within the company. Balanchine admired Tomlinson’s talent and experience with his repertoire, having performed so many Balanchine works with DTH. Balanchine adored Tomlinson so much as a dancer, that he was in the process of creating a ballet with him in mind when he died. In his memoir, Beyond My Dreams, Tomlinson remembers the first time he went into Balanchine’s office and, after he commented favorably on one of Balanchine’s armchairs, Balanchine gave it to him. Tomlinson remembers Balanchine’s immense kindness and claims that the three years dancing for Balanchine were the best years of his life.


Heather Watts

Tomlinson’s most famous performance took place with the New York City Ballet in 1981, when he danced Agon with Heather Watts. This pas de deux was previously performed by Diana Adams and Arthur Mitchell, designed to emphasize the contrast between dark and light, as Agon means conflict/competition. Choreographed by Balanchine, this piece was Tomlinson’s debut performance with NYCB. In addition to the apparent dichotomy of black and white, there also was a contrast between Tomlinson’s tall, strong, calm body, and Watts’s smaller, more nervous body. Watts remembers, in her foreword to Tomlinson’s memoirs, that “Mel was unfailingly kind, patient and professional, and he quickly made a home for himself at NYCB.” Balanchine was so interested in the difference in skin tones between the dancers, that he lied to Tomlinson, claiming that Watts’s previous partner had hurt his back and needed replacing, in order to get Tomlinson into the role. Tomlinson remembers that Heather was nothing short of professional, while also being so kind and making sure he felt comfortable in the piece, as this was their first time dancing together.


Jerome Robbins

After Balanchine’s death in 1983, Jerome Robbins and Peter Martins took over as co-artistic directors of New York City Ballet, though Martins had been Balanchine’s personal choice of successor. The process of changing over to new artistic directors meant that Mel Tomlinson wasn’t able to get on stage as often, as it seemed Robbins and Martins preferred using white dancers. Tomlinson honestly reveals in his memoir, Beyond My Dreams, that “although my relationship with Jerry was never smooth or comfortable, I am very grateful that I got to work with him.” Tomlinson remembers Robbins’s work as being full of life, because he knew his dancers very well and wished to make the dances work for their style and body. Robbins’ choreography was excellent due to his deep connection to the music and his strong relationship with Leonard Bernstein, composer he often worked with. This does not excuse the fact that he was openly racist and made many dancers feel vulnerable in his presence, due to his constant degrading of their talent and his desperate desire for perfection. He is part of the reason why Tomlinson decided to leave NYCB soon after Balanchine’s death.


Salvatore Aiello (North Carolina Dance Theatre)

Mel Tomlinson teaching a class at his old middle school in North Carolina.
Mel Tomlinson teaching a class at his old middle school in North Carolina.

Tomlinson left NYCB and returned to North Carolina to teach at his alma mater but found a way to continue his dance career thanks to North Carolina Dance Theatre. Salvatore Aiello was the artistic director and resident choreographer of the company at the time and gave Tomlinson many roles, including in Afternoon of a Faun. Aiello gave Tomlinson a lot of artistic freedom in this piece, as he did with most of his dancers, making the choreography a collaborative and adventurous experience. During his time at North Carolina Dance Theatre, Tomlinson had the opportunity to dance alongside many dancers, including Jeanette Makaroff, Anita Intrieri, Katherine Thompson, and Helen Rosenthal, who all played the four nymphs that frightened and intrigued Tomlinson, the faun, in Afternoon of a Faun in 1988. Additionally, Tracy Owens danced with Tomlinson in the company. An article from a 🔑 local North Carolina newspaper explains that they were the two strongest dancers in the company. Their first pas de deux was called By Lamplight, and Tracy Owens remembers it as one of her favorite pieces.


Tomlinson joined the company at a time when it was struggling financially, but despite the harsh work conditions, Tomlinson and Aiello got along really well. Aiello, in addition to bringing Tomlinson on as a principal, made him the Education Director, in charge of outreach programs for younger dancers. 

North Carolina Dance Theatre was the professional company affiliated with North Carolina School of the Arts, where Tomlinson attended high school and college. The company was fully integrated since the beginning and now operates under the title “Charlotte Ballet.” 


Bruce Marks (Boston Ballet)

Finally, Tomlinson came out of retirement to dance again at Boston Ballet beginning in 1991, where Bruce Marks was the artistic director. Marks was recognized by the dance world for inspiring inclusion and equity with the Boston Ballet CITYDANCE program, which Mel Tomlinson helped to craft while teaching and dancing with the company. CITYDANCE is a year-long program where 3,000 third grade students from public schools around Boston get to study dance at no tuition cost for a year. This program was successful from the outset and is the model other companies around the country have looked to when forming similar outreach initiatives. Though Tomlinson had some disagreements with his other co-director of CITYDANCE, he loved the children. One of his students, Ebony Williams, went on to become one of Beyonce’s dancers.

While with the company, Tomlinson would teach company class when it was time for the company to learn or perform a Balanchine work, as Tomlinson’s extensive career with New York City Ballet and Dance Theatre of Harlem gave him plenty of exposure to the speed and specificity of a Balanchine’s technique. While there, Tomlinson had the opportunity to work with Carla Stallings, Kyra Strasberg, Julie Bacon, Adriana Suarez, and Jennifer Gelfand. 

Tomlinson’s dedication to his craft ended up taking him around the country, as he danced his way into the heart of many professional dancers at the time. His legacy lives on today, as we celebrate all of the advancement he made in terms of bringing his darker shade to numerous stages, in addition to his strength and musicality. 


Casey Monteiro


Leave a Reply